For educational purposes only. Not tax, legal, or financial advice. Tax laws change frequently. Consult a registered tax agent or CPA for your specific situation.

    Skip to content
    TaxKiln Australia
    TaxKilnAustralia tax guidance

    10 Expensive Australian Tax Mistakes

    Ten mistakes with real dollar costs: from late GST registration and missing logbooks to Division 7A traps and incorporating too early. Each mistake includes what it costs, why it happens, and how to avoid it.

    The ten most expensive tax mistakes for Australian small businesses and sole traders collectively cost thousands to tens of thousands of dollars per year. The costliest is failing to register for GST at the $75,000 threshold, which can produce backdated GST of $13,636 on $150,000 of sales plus GIC interest at approximately 11 per cent and penalties. From 1 July 2025, GIC is no longer deductible, making every late payment and compliance error permanently more expensive in after-tax terms. Administrative penalties are calculated in penalty units of $330 each (from 7 November 2024, indexed 1 July 2026).

    Last reviewed:

    Guidance, not advice. We explain the rules, we don't assess your situation. Always seek financial or tax advice from your accountant, or contact ATO. Read our editorial scope →

    1. Not registering for GST at $75,000

    The ATO requires GST registration once your GST turnover reaches or is projected to reach $75,000 in a rolling 12-month period. The mistake is crossing this threshold without registering, often because turnover creeps up gradually or the 12-month rolling calculation is not tracked.

    2. Missing PAYG instalment deadlines

    PAYG instalments are quarterly prepayments of your expected income tax. Missing due dates triggers GIC, which accrues daily at approximately 11 per cent annualised. From 1 July 2025, GIC is no longer deductible, so the after-tax cost of every late payment has increased permanently.

    3. Not keeping a valid motor vehicle logbook

    The logbook method allows you to claim the business-use percentage of all vehicle running costs (fuel, insurance, registration, repairs, depreciation). Without a valid 12-week logbook, you are limited to the cents-per-kilometre method, which caps at 5,000 business kilometres per year regardless of actual use.

    The dollar gap

    With $15,000 in total car costs and 60 per cent genuine business use, a valid logbook supports a $9,000 deduction. Without it, the cents-per-kilometre method caps your claim at approximately $4,000 (5,000 km at 88 cents). Over several years, that gap compounds to $5,000 to $15,000 in lost deductions.

    4. Home office occupancy claimed without exclusive-use test

    Occupancy expenses (rent, mortgage interest, rates, insurance) can only be claimed for a home office that meets the exclusive-use criteria and genuinely has the character of a place of business. Claiming occupancy without meeting these tests exposes you to deduction disallowance, penalties, GIC on the shortfall, and potential capital gains tax implications on your main residence.

    5. Late super payments (Super Guarantee Charge)

    Employer super contributions must reach the employee's fund by the 28th day after the end of each quarter. Late payments trigger the Super Guarantee Charge, which includes the shortfall, 10 per cent interest from the start of the quarter, and $20 per employee per quarter in administration fees. The SGC is not tax-deductible.

    6. Not understanding PSI rules before incorporating

    Setting up a company or trust for income that is really Personal Services Income (more than 50 per cent of contract payments for your personal labour, skills, or expertise) without passing one of the Personal Services Business tests produces no tax benefit. The ATO attributes the income back to you at individual marginal rates, and you wear $3,000 to $5,000 per year in extra compliance costs (bookkeeping, company returns, ASIC fees) for no saving.

    7. Mixing personal and business expenses

    Running personal spending through a business account, or claiming mixed-purpose costs as fully deductible without apportionment, is one of the most common audit triggers. The ATO uses data matching and bank transaction analysis to identify patterns inconsistent with the claimed business activity.

    The cost of $10,000 in overstated deductions

    At a 34.5 per cent marginal rate (including Medicare levy), $10,000 in disallowed deductions produces $3,450 in additional tax, plus GIC from the original due date and a penalty of 25 per cent (reasonable care) to 75 per cent (intentional disregard) of the shortfall. Separate bank accounts and cards. For mixed costs (phone, internet, vehicle, home office), apportion based on reasonable records and keep the evidence.

    8. Not claiming the instant asset write-off

    The instant asset write-off allows eligible small businesses (aggregated turnover under $10 million) to deduct the full cost of business assets under $20,000 in the year they are first used or installed. The mistake is depreciating qualifying assets slowly over multiple years when an immediate deduction is available.

    9. Ignoring non-commercial loss rules

    Division 35 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 quarantines losses from non-commercial business activities, preventing them from offsetting salary, investment, or other income. A $15,000 loss you expected to reduce your overall tax bill is carried forward instead, increasing your current-year liability.

    The four tests

    Your business activity must meet at least one: assessable income of $20,000 or more from the activity, profit in three of the last five years (including the current year), real property valued at $500,000 or more used on a continuing basis, or other assets valued at $100,000 or more used on a continuing basis. If none are met, the loss is quarantined.

    10. Incorporating too early

    The classic error: forming a company at $80,000 to $90,000 profit (often PSI), pulling all money out as salary or drawings, paying ASIC fees every year, and paying an accountant for the company return, director minutes, and compliance work. The net effect is no real tax saving, several thousand dollars of annual friction, and Division 7A risk on any casual drawings.

    The penalties and interest context

    Administrative penalties are calculated in penalty units ($330 per unit from 7 November 2024, indexed 1 July 2026). GIC runs at approximately 11 per cent annualised, compounding daily. The removal of GIC deductibility from 1 July 2025 means the after-tax cost of every mistake listed above is materially higher than in prior years. Combined, these changes make prevention (proper registration, timely lodgement, accurate records, and appropriate structure advice) significantly cheaper than correction.

    Statute references

    • A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999, Division 23 (GST registration threshold)
    • Tax Administration Act 1953, Division 284 (administrative penalties)
    • Tax Administration Act 1953, Part IIA (General Interest Charge)
    • Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, Division 35 (non-commercial losses)
    • Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, Part 2-42 (Personal Services Income)
    • Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, Subdivision 328-D (instant asset write-off for small business entities)
    • Superannuation Guarantee (Administration) Act 1992 (Super Guarantee Charge)
    • Income Tax Assessment Act 1936, Division 7A (deemed dividends from private companies)

    Frequently asked questions

    How much does a late GST registration actually cost?+
    The ATO can backdate GST registration to the date you should have registered. On $150,000 of taxable sales over 18 months without registration, backdated GST is approximately $13,636 (dividing by 11). You owe this from your own pocket because you did not charge GST to your clients at the time. GIC interest at approximately 11 per cent accrues from the original due dates, and administrative penalties apply on top. Set an internal trigger at approximately $65,000 rolling turnover to check whether registration is needed.
    Why is the Super Guarantee Charge so punitive?+
    The Super Guarantee Charge includes the shortfall amount on ordinary time earnings, 10 per cent interest calculated from the start of the quarter, and a $20 administrative component per employee per quarter. Critically, the SGC is not tax-deductible, unlike on-time super payments which are. Even a few days late across several employees compounds into thousands per year. The only defence is paying on time via a SuperStream-compliant clearing house.
    Can I claim the instant asset write-off on a second-hand vehicle?+
    Yes. The instant asset write-off applies to new and second-hand assets, provided the asset costs less than $20,000 (2025-26 threshold), is first used or installed ready for use in the income year, and your business has aggregated turnover under $10 million. For vehicles, the car cost limit ($69,674 for 2025-26) caps the depreciable amount regardless of the write-off threshold.
    What are the non-commercial loss tests and why do they matter?+
    Division 35 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 prevents you from offsetting business losses against other income (salary, investment) unless your business activity meets one of four tests: $20,000 or more in assessable income, profit in three of the last five years (including the current year), real property valued at $500,000 or more used on a continuing basis, or other assets valued at $100,000 or more used on a continuing basis. If none are met, the loss is quarantined and carried forward to offset future profits from that activity.

    Last reviewed: